PDA

View Full Version : Beer prices up yet again... again! Should the Brewer Retail be disbanded? Hey Dalton!


cattersley
07-19-2008, 01:41 PM
So... after reading an article in the Toronto Star about the Brewers Retail's monopoly on large pack purchases of beer in Ontario it got my blood boiling yet again about the issue.

An online poll/petition conducted on 24 hrs after that article was printed urging Premiere Dalton's "Fiberal" government to look at consumer distain about the Beer Store had 3000 people sign it, and will likely be igored.

When asked about the question of the Beer Store (Where one of his son's is employed BTW) and consumers choices, prices, etc, Dalton's answer was if it isn't broke don' fix it. Well it has been broken for a long time. The Beer Store pushes out the little brewers in Ontario, raises prices at there leisure because they can, and we as the consumer take it... because really if we can't influsence of elected representatives to change this system what the hell can we do really? The brewers retail say 50% sin taxes on the price is the real reason for high prices, and that is partly to blame yes, but raising the price of your beer 15 - 25 cents a case every six monthes consistently since I have been 17, I am 26 now, might also be part of that. Don't get me wrong inflation happens and with the price of gas things go up in price, but I work at a small brewery, I no how much water, malt, hops, and yeast costs, and I also no the big brewers get a huge, and I mean huge discount from there suppliers, and lock into prices for years. Meaning if the prices go up, they still pay the same price years on end until the contract is up for renegotiation. The Beer Store also tells the consumer that selection will suffer if the are disbanded. Well I was in the USA recently, and NY State for example the super markets there had over 50 - 100 different choices. There craft selection blew me away. In North/South Carolina a chain of all organic stores had over 150 beers to choose from, even be able to mix-a-six for the same price as most six-packs! Selection will suffer, bull-shit.

Here is the point of my rant. The Beer Store should be disbanded. Think about this... if the goverment went to the big three automakers, or petroleum produces and said you and you only can sell car or gas in Ontario how would you as citizens react? So why should we tolerate this in regards to beer???! Quebec and the USA has systems in place to ensure minors arn't getting alcohol in there hands, so the polictical players that be and lobby groups think that Ontario will be a "sin-bin" full of underage drunks if beer is sold in super markets, and corner shops??? This will no happen. Governments shouldn't police there citizens to the point that they are the parents an us law abiding Ontarian's are there over taxed, choice restricted "children".

Bottom line, we need a free system to encourage price compition, lower taxes (doupt that will ever happen), and government will to "choose change" to represent the majority of beer drinkers that want this. "Choose change", kinda has a ring to it eh Dalton?!

I plan on writing my local MP, and MPP, I urge you all to do the same. I also urge you all to try brew your own stores, start home brewering or hell, hit the border and go to NY State.

So, lets here you opinion on beer prices, the Beer Store, and the Ontario Liberal Government.

"RESPECT BEER!"

Regards, cattersley.

shugalou
07-24-2008, 03:17 PM
Nice rant Catt,

Honestly - F the government, they don't give a hell about the people that continue to fund the system. Instead they continue to raise the cost of everything around us so we can continue to support the terrible management of money within the system.

The only way things will change is if people start boycotting the purchase of beer (which will be difficult) then the gov won't have the money they are used getting from beer sales and they will have to change something in order to get that money again..If it ever got to that point though I'm sure they would just make it illegal to brew your own and shut down the Brew on Site premisses to keep business flowing to the beer store.

I haven't bought a 24 is a long time and when I have to I will grab the cheap stuff (Mclays) because I can't justify paying almost 40 for a case.

There is no time like the present to get into homebrewing. One you have all your equipment it will only cost about 15 bucks for apx. 50 beers...and you gain an entirely new appreciation for beer and you can make beers better than most commercial beers.

This weekend I'm bringing up 4 kegs of homebrew to a cottage party. Everyone wants to give me money since I'm saving them a bunch of money by supplying the beer but I'm not accepting any since this is my thank you for having my family up at the cottage. 20L kegs at the beer store go for around 90 bucks each! $60 vs $360 and deposits and pump rentals and all that other B.S.
.

ontap78
07-25-2008, 10:27 AM
40 Bucks a case! No wonder the first question they ask at the border is, " how much beer are you bringing in with you?". By all means, brew you own. I have been brewing my own for years and beer is little over a third the price here as opposed to Ontario. I still buy a little commercial beer, but if I had to pay 40 bucks for it, I'd be making ALL of my beer.

shugalou
07-25-2008, 10:50 AM
Yeah what's crazy is you can go across the boarder buy a case of Molson Canadian for 16 bucks and that same case of beer in Ontario (where it was brewed) will cost you $36.95.

shugalou
07-25-2008, 10:53 AM
Oh and a 20L keg goes for 96.50 here...damn!

ontap78
07-25-2008, 10:55 AM
Yeah, and I'm sure Molson sold here in Minnesota isn't 37 bucks either. If it was, they wouldn't sell any at all. It's not really very special after all.

shugalou
07-25-2008, 11:35 AM
I second that - it's a beer that is marketed very heavily to the masses and most people think that this is the pinacle of Canadian beers and even identify with it. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BRI-A3vakVg

markaberrant
07-25-2008, 12:03 PM
I don't really care what the price of Molson is. In fact, I'm glad the prices for macro-spew are outrageous in Canada, it makes it that much easier for someone to crossover, as it is only a dollar or two more per 6-pack for good craft beer.

I also don't care about the BeerStore being a monopoly. They sell crap beer. LCBOs are starting to carry more and more good stuff, and breweries can sell retail onsite. Beer tastes better the closer you get to the source.

cattersley
07-26-2008, 11:17 AM
Yes, fresh beer at the source is excellent... I have had my fair share working at a number of breweries, but the point is about an over-parenting government that taxes it's citizen’s convincing them that being treated like 13year-olds raising the price on us is for the great good of "social responsibility". A government owned or endorsed private monopoly shouldn't be tolerated. The excuse of minors being able to afford or getting there hands on alcohol for the reason of not bringing in a deregulated system is bull-s**t plan and simple. Human nature, if people want something they will get it. I was underage once, so were the rest of you, probably didn't stop the majority of getting there hands on alcohol, and it didn't stop me either. Has Quebec turned all its young citizens into alocholics because they have they the sense to allow corner stores and markets to sell beer and wine? No... not at all.

Now on the notion of craft beer, just because something is labelled "craft" beer doesn't make it good beer. It also doesn't justify charging more money because of this sense. Yes smaller brewers have different issues, it doesn't help when the beer store and LCBO charges a fee anywhere from 15,000$ - 25,000$ just for shelf-space before even stocking the product! The average "craft beer" can sell anywhere from 40 - 55 $ a 24 in Ontario. That is insane. Going to the USA is great. I come home with selection of craft beers that range in price from 17 to 22 $ a case, and they are usually mixed packs over a huge selection of different styles to sample.

Yes the LCBO does have a wide selection of great beers, so does the SAQ in Quebec (which has even more interesting beers from Europe you can't get at the LCBO), but go into any market in NY State or specialty beer store... there selection kicks the LCBO's/SAQ's ass is selection and especially price. Price is the bottom line. Every person no matter what income they are making has a right not to be forced into the poor house to enjoy a legal product. The brewing industry in Canada is apart of our heritage, and national identity. When governments tact on a couple of cents here and there (McGuinty's first term on imported 24's in Ontario), a brewer like Molson and Labatt consistently raises prices every 3 - 6 months (20 - 45 cents a case), over time this adds up. That is why our sin taxes are in the tops five highest in the world. Quebec has higher sin taxes then Ontario, about 3 % higher, yet a big brewery beer at Super C is 22.95$ - 24, and craft beer is any where in the range of 30 - 35 $ a 24. So why are we paying more?! Enough is enough...

I emailed Premiere McGuinty, and my local MPP John O'Toole of the Ontario Conservative Party. Not so surprising my Premiere had no response, but what a very nice surprise was that my MPP John O'Toole not only wrote me back, but called my house. Responding he said he has heard the concern that many people in my riding has expressed to him about the Beer Store monopoly, and has sent a letter to a Minister in the Liberal Cabinet on the matter... nothing will likely come of it, but it is a start though, and I won't give up. If McGuinty won't respond to my email, maybe he will respond to a letter to his office once a week, every week for a bloody year!

http://www.superc.ca/fr/circulaire.html - Super C weekly flyer.

Cheer all, and as always RESPECT BEER...

Regards, cattersley.

PS: On a side note, the new commericals calling the reinvented Steelback as "craft beer" at the price of regular beer, ie - 36.95$ - a 24, your not fooling anyone...

markaberrant
07-26-2008, 02:10 PM
I hear ya Cattersley, good on you, and I am on your side. We've got a similar problem in Saskatchewan, but it just doesn't phase me. I've figured out how to access a steady supply of great beer without the provincial government or large breweries seeing one cent of my money. If everyone else wants to be a bunch of sheep and buy overpriced shit beer from the government, then be my guest.

There is a lot of momentum in Ontario right now for change to occur, but in the end I really don't see prices going down.

cattersley
07-26-2008, 04:10 PM
There is a huge need for change, and people willing to work to change it. I am finnally sick and tired enough to try and get the change in motion, or at least help in some way. Every little bit counts, and if everyone tries, change will eventually start to happen.

Cheers!

- cattersley.